The Horizontal Effect Revolution and the Question of Sovereignty

Author: Walt Johan van der  

Publisher: De Gruyter‎

Publication year: 2014

E-ISBN: 9783110248036

P-ISBN(Paperback): 9783110248029

P-ISBN(Hardback):  9783110248029

Subject: D911 国家法、宪法

Keyword: 国家法、宪法

Language: ENG

Access to resources Favorite

Disclaimer: Any content in publications that violate the sovereignty, the constitution or regulations of the PRC is not accepted or approved by CNPIEC.

Chapter

VI Liberal Democratic Constitutional Review

VI Liberal Democratic Constitutional Review

VI Liberal Democratic Constitutional Review

VII Outline of Arguments and Chapters

VII Outline of Arguments and Chapters

VII Outline of Arguments and Chapters

Part One: Horizontal Effect

Part One: Horizontal Effect

Part One: Horizontal Effect

Chapter One: Erased Baselines and Inversed Coordinates: 19th Century Backgrounds of the Horizontality Question

Chapter One: Erased Baselines and Inversed Coordinates: 19th Century Backgrounds of the Horizontality Question

Chapter One: Erased Baselines and Inversed Coordinates: 19th Century Backgrounds of the Horizontality Question

I Introduction

I Introduction

I Introduction

II The Privatisation of Constitutional Rights in America

II The Privatisation of Constitutional Rights in America

II The Privatisation of Constitutional Rights in America

III The Nineteenth Century Transformation of Private Law Rights in America

III The Nineteenth Century Transformation of Private Law Rights in America

III The Nineteenth Century Transformation of Private Law Rights in America

IV The Privatisation of Constitutional Rights in Germany

IV The Privatisation of Constitutional Rights in Germany

IV The Privatisation of Constitutional Rights in Germany

V The Nineteenth Century Transformation of Private Law Rights in Germany and its Impact on Early Twentieth Century German Public Law

V The Nineteenth Century Transformation of Private Law Rights in Germany and its Impact on Early Twentieth Century German Public Law

V The Nineteenth Century Transformation of Private Law Rights in Germany and its Impact on Early Twentieth Century German Public Law

VI The Baseline of Erased Baselines

VI The Baseline of Erased Baselines

VI The Baseline of Erased Baselines

VII Inversed Coordinates

VII Inversed Coordinates

VII Inversed Coordinates

Chapter Two: Twelve Pivotal Cases

Chapter Two: Twelve Pivotal Cases

Chapter Two: Twelve Pivotal Cases

I Introduction

I Introduction

I Introduction

II The Civil Rights Cases (and their Unlikely South African Echoes)

II The Civil Rights Cases (and their Unlikely South African Echoes)

II The Civil Rights Cases (and their Unlikely South African Echoes)

III Shelley v Kraemer

III Shelley v Kraemer

III Shelley v Kraemer

IV Labour v Swing and New York Times v Sullivan

IV Labour v Swing and New York Times v Sullivan

IV Labour v Swing and New York Times v Sullivan

V RWDSU v Dolphin Delivery Ltd

V RWDSU v Dolphin Delivery Ltd

V RWDSU v Dolphin Delivery Ltd

VI Lüth

VI Lüth

VI Lüth

VII Du Plessis v De Klerk

VII Du Plessis v De Klerk

VII Du Plessis v De Klerk

VIII Flagg Brothers, Inc. v Brooks

VIII Flagg Brothers, Inc. v Brooks

VIII Flagg Brothers, Inc. v Brooks

IX DeShaney v Winnebago County Department of Social Services

IX DeShaney v Winnebago County Department of Social Services

IX DeShaney v Winnebago County Department of Social Services

X The Duty to Protect: Roe v Wade and Erste Abtreibung

X The Duty to Protect: Roe v Wade and Erste Abtreibung

X The Duty to Protect: Roe v Wade and Erste Abtreibung

XI Reiten im Walde

XI Reiten im Walde

XI Reiten im Walde

XII Summary Reflections

XII Summary Reflections

XII Summary Reflections

1 Vicissitudes of the State Action Doctrine

1 Vicissitudes of the State Action Doctrine

1 Vicissitudes of the State Action Doctrine

2 The Contradictory Legacies that Informed Du Plessis

2 The Contradictory Legacies that Informed Du Plessis

2 The Contradictory Legacies that Informed Du Plessis

3 The Dismantling of Swing, Shelley and Sullivan in Flagg Brothers and DeShaney

3 The Dismantling of Swing, Shelley and Sullivan in Flagg Brothers and DeShaney

3 The Dismantling of Swing, Shelley and Sullivan in Flagg Brothers and DeShaney

4 Shifting Horizontal Effect Jurisprudence from Private to Legislative Relations

4 Shifting Horizontal Effect Jurisprudence from Private to Legislative Relations

4 Shifting Horizontal Effect Jurisprudence from Private to Legislative Relations

5 Substantive and Procedural Due Process and the Question of Sovereignty

5 Substantive and Procedural Due Process and the Question of Sovereignty

5 Substantive and Procedural Due Process and the Question of Sovereignty

6 Constitutional Histories of Peoples

6 Constitutional Histories of Peoples

6 Constitutional Histories of Peoples

Chapter Three: State Action

Chapter Three: State Action

Chapter Three: State Action

I Introduction

I Introduction

I Introduction

II Michelman’s “Hohfeldian Point”

II Michelman’s “Hohfeldian Point”

II Michelman’s “Hohfeldian Point”

III Wechsler and Tribe: Two Readings of Shelley

III Wechsler and Tribe: Two Readings of Shelley

III Wechsler and Tribe: Two Readings of Shelley

IV Seidman’s Reading of DeShaney

IV Seidman’s Reading of DeShaney

IV Seidman’s Reading of DeShaney

V One Way out of the American Conceptual Impasse

V One Way out of the American Conceptual Impasse

V One Way out of the American Conceptual Impasse

Chapter Four: Drittwirkung

Chapter Four: Drittwirkung

Chapter Four: Drittwirkung

I Introduction

I Introduction

I Introduction

II Nipperdey’s Position

II Nipperdey’s Position

II Nipperdey’s Position

III Dürig’s Position

III Dürig’s Position

III Dürig’s Position

IV Leisner’s Position

IV Leisner’s Position

IV Leisner’s Position

V Schwabe’s Position

V Schwabe’s Position

V Schwabe’s Position

VI Canaris’ Response

VI Canaris’ Response

VI Canaris’ Response

VII Schutzpflicht and/or Drittwirkung?

VII Schutzpflicht and/or Drittwirkung?

VII Schutzpflicht and/or Drittwirkung?

Part Two: Sovereignty

Part Two: Sovereignty

Part Two: Sovereignty

Chapter Five: Uninterrupted Sovereignty

Chapter Five: Uninterrupted Sovereignty

Chapter Five: Uninterrupted Sovereignty

I Introduction

I Introduction

I Introduction

II Divided Sovereignty

II Divided Sovereignty

II Divided Sovereignty

III Between Deism and Deontology – Europe and Ordo-Liberalism

III Between Deism and Deontology – Europe and Ordo-Liberalism

III Between Deism and Deontology – Europe and Ordo-Liberalism

IV Dispersed Sovereignty – Government and Governance

IV Dispersed Sovereignty – Government and Governance

IV Dispersed Sovereignty – Government and Governance

V Dispensed Sovereignty – The Davidsonian Road to Luhmann

V Dispensed Sovereignty – The Davidsonian Road to Luhmann

V Dispensed Sovereignty – The Davidsonian Road to Luhmann

VI Uninterrupted Sovereignty – A “Luhmannian” Return to Hegel

VI Uninterrupted Sovereignty – A “Luhmannian” Return to Hegel

VI Uninterrupted Sovereignty – A “Luhmannian” Return to Hegel

Chapter Six: Différantial Sovereignty

Chapter Six: Différantial Sovereignty

Chapter Six: Différantial Sovereignty

I Introduction

I Introduction

I Introduction

II Coercive Enlightenment Ideals

II Coercive Enlightenment Ideals

II Coercive Enlightenment Ideals

III Carl Schmitt’s Unitary Substantive Due Process and Indirect Horizontal Effect Jurisprudence

III Carl Schmitt’s Unitary Substantive Due Process and Indirect Horizontal Effect Jurisprudence

III Carl Schmitt’s Unitary Substantive Due Process and Indirect Horizontal Effect Jurisprudence

IV Hans Kelsen and the Open Duality of the Constitutional Democratic Whole

IV Hans Kelsen and the Open Duality of the Constitutional Democratic Whole

IV Hans Kelsen and the Open Duality of the Constitutional Democratic Whole

V Leisner’s “Kelsenian” Horizontal Effect Jurisprudence

V Leisner’s “Kelsenian” Horizontal Effect Jurisprudence

V Leisner’s “Kelsenian” Horizontal Effect Jurisprudence

VI Différantial Sovereignty

VI Différantial Sovereignty

VI Différantial Sovereignty

Chapter Seven: Sovereignty and the Dual Destiny of Lüth in Europe

Chapter Seven: Sovereignty and the Dual Destiny of Lüth in Europe

Chapter Seven: Sovereignty and the Dual Destiny of Lüth in Europe

I Introduction

I Introduction

I Introduction

II The Rise of European Union Sovereignty

II The Rise of European Union Sovereignty

II The Rise of European Union Sovereignty

III The Demise of German Sovereignty and the Marginalisation of Lüth in Germany

III The Demise of German Sovereignty and the Marginalisation of Lüth in Germany

III The Demise of German Sovereignty and the Marginalisation of Lüth in Germany

IV European Union Sovereignty – Vertical and Monistic or Horizontal and Différantial?

IV European Union Sovereignty – Vertical and Monistic or Horizontal and Différantial?

IV European Union Sovereignty – Vertical and Monistic or Horizontal and Différantial?

Chapter Eight: Liberal Democratic Constitutional Review

Chapter Eight: Liberal Democratic Constitutional Review

Chapter Eight: Liberal Democratic Constitutional Review

I Introduction

I Introduction

I Introduction

II The Recognition of Sovereignty

II The Recognition of Sovereignty

II The Recognition of Sovereignty

III Liberal Democratic Sovereignty

III Liberal Democratic Sovereignty

III Liberal Democratic Sovereignty

IV Substantive and Procedural Due Process Constitutional Review

IV Substantive and Procedural Due Process Constitutional Review

IV Substantive and Procedural Due Process Constitutional Review

V The Proceduralisation of Minimum Substance and the First Proportionality Question

V The Proceduralisation of Minimum Substance and the First Proportionality Question

V The Proceduralisation of Minimum Substance and the First Proportionality Question

VI The Second Proportionality Question: Rationality and Effectiveness

VI The Second Proportionality Question: Rationality and Effectiveness

VI The Second Proportionality Question: Rationality and Effectiveness

VII The Third Proportionality Question: Minimal Intrusion

VII The Third Proportionality Question: Minimal Intrusion

VII The Third Proportionality Question: Minimal Intrusion

VIII The Difference between Ordinary and Constitutional Law

VIII The Difference between Ordinary and Constitutional Law

VIII The Difference between Ordinary and Constitutional Law

IX Social Liberal Democracy?

IX Social Liberal Democracy?

IX Social Liberal Democracy?

Bibliography

Bibliography

Bibliography

Abbreviations

Abbreviations

Abbreviations

Index of Persons

Index of Persons

Index of Persons

Subject Index

Subject Index

Subject Index

The users who browse this book also browse