The Clash of Economic Ideas :The Great Policy Debates and Experiments of the Last Hundred Years

Publication subTitle :The Great Policy Debates and Experiments of the Last Hundred Years

Author: Lawrence H. White  

Publisher: Cambridge University Press‎

Publication year: 2012

E-ISBN: 9781139368872

P-ISBN(Paperback): 9781107012424

Subject: F0 Economics

Keyword: 经济学Economics

Language: ENG

Access to resources Favorite

Disclaimer: Any content in publications that violate the sovereignty, the constitution or regulations of the PRC is not accepted or approved by CNPIEC.

The Clash of Economic Ideas

Description

The Clash of Economic Ideas interweaves the economic history of the last hundred years with the history of economic doctrines to understand how contrasting economic ideas have originated and developed over time to take their present forms. It traces the connections running from historical events to debates among economists, and from the ideas of academic writers to major experiments in economic policy. The treatment offers fresh perspectives on laissez faire, socialism and fascism; the Roaring Twenties, business cycle theories and the Great Depression; Institutionalism and the New Deal; the Keynesian Revolution; and war, nationalization and central planning. After 1945, the work explores the postwar revival of invisible-hand ideas; economic development and growth, with special attention to contrasting policies and thought in Germany and India; the gold standard, the interwar gold-exchange standard, the postwar Bretton Woods system and the Great Inflation; public goods and public choice; free trade versus protectionism; and finally fiscal policy and public debt.

Chapter

THE BOLSHEVIKS MAKE ECONOMIC POLICY

VIENNA 1920

LUDWIG VON MISES

MISES’S CRITIQUE OF THE SOCIALIST ECONOMY

SOVIET SHORTAGES

THE NEED FOR INPUT PRICES

“CRUSOE” PRODUCTION VERSUS SPECIALIZED PRODUCTION AND TRADE

WHICH PRODUCTION PROJECTS ARE WORTH IT?

THE PROFIT TEST MAKES “INTELLECTUAL DIVISION OF LABOR” POSSIBLE

WHY NOT VALUATION BY LABOR INPUT?

THE LABOR THEORY OF VALUE AND ITS PROBLEMS

THE PROBLEM OF INCENTIVE UNDER SOCIALISM

OSKAR LANGE’S RESPONSE TO MISES’S CHALLENGE

OSKAR LANGE

LANGE’S ANSWER TO MISES

HOW DOES THE SOCIALIST PLANNING MINISTRY GAIN THE KNOWLEDGE IT NEEDS?

DETERMINING PRICES FOR INPUTS WITHOUT MARKETS

WHY PREFER SOCIALISM, IF IT MERELY REPLICATES COMPETITIVE MARKETS?

MISES’S RESPONSE TO LANGE

HAYEK’S INITIAL CRITIQUE OF MARKET SOCIALISM AND LANGE’S LETTER IN REPLY

KEY INFORMATION IS DISPERSED

WHO PLANS FOR WHOM?

MARKETS COORDINATE DECENTRALIZED PLANS THROUGH PRICE SIGNALS

THE CORRECT PRICES FOR INPUTS DO NOT FOLLOW FROM OUTPUT PRICES ALONE

LANGE AS A CENTRAL PLANNER IN PRACTICE

THE VARIED INFLUENCE OF HAYEK’S ARGUMENT

DID THE COLLAPSE OF THE SOVIET ECONOMY SHOW THAT MISES WAS RIGHT?

CHANGING VIEWS OF THE SOCIALIST CALCULATION DEBATE

WITH ITS THEORY IN TATTERS, WHERE DOES SOCIALISM GO?

3: The Roaring Twenties and Austrian Business Cycle Theory

THE ROARING TWENTIES

PRE-KEYNESIAN MACROECONOMICS

THE MISES-HAYEK THEORY OF THE BOOM-BUST CYCLE

HAYEK VERSUS KEYNES’S TREATISE

THE HAYEKIAN TRIANGLE

WHY BUST FOLLOWS BOOM

HAYEK’S POLICY PRESCRIPTION

IN A GROWING ECONOMY, PRICES SHOULD FALL

EUGEN VON BÖHM-BAWERK’S THEORY OF INTEREST

MISES, WICKSELL, AND THE BRITISH “CURRENCY SCHOOL”

THE CURRENCY, FREE BANKING, AND BANKING SCHOOL

CRITICISMS OF HAYEK’S THEORY

DID HAYEK AND ROBBINS DEEPEN THE GREAT DEPRESSION?

THE REAL BILLS DOCTRINE VERSUS THE AUSTRIAN CYCLE THEORY

4: The New Deal and Institutionalist Economics

FRANKLIN ROOSEVELT AND THE COMMAND-ECONOMY MODEL

FRANKLIN DELANO ROOSEVELT (FDR) AND THE NRA

THE THEORY BEHIND THE NRA

UNDERCONSUMPTION AND J. A. HOBSON

ECONOMIC AND LEGAL PROBLEMS WITH THE NRA AND AAA

INSTITUTIONALIST ECONOMICS

TUGWELL’S BACKGROUND

SIMON PATTEN

THORSTEIN VEBLEN

AMERICAN INSTITUTIONALISM AND GERMAN HISTORICISM

INSTITUTIONALISM AND SOCIALISM

TAYLORISM

THE PRINCIPLE OF PLANNING

THE INSTITUTIONALIST LEGACY

5: The Great Depression and Keynes’s General Theory

THE DEPTHS OF THE DEPRESSION

KEYNES’S DIAGNOSIS

DID KEYNES “INVENT MACROECONOMICS”?

WHAT WAS NEW IN KEYNES

THE PARADOX OF THRIFT

THE LIQUIDITY-PREFERENCE THEORY OF INTEREST

HAYEK VERSUS KEYNES’S GENERAL THEORY

KEYNES VERSUS “CLASSICAL” ECONOMICS

MALTHUS AND SISMONDI VERSUS RICARDO AND SAY ON UNDERCONSUMPTION

SAY’S LAW OF MARKETS

AN IMPORTANT CAVEAT

KEYNES’S CRITIQUE OF SAY

WHAT THE GENERAL THEORY OFFERED

DEPRESSION THEORY VERSUS BUSINESS CYCLE THEORY

WHY KEYNES’S THEORY CAUGHT ON

KEYNESIAN ECONOMICS AFTER KEYNES: THE IS-LM MODEL

INFLATION AND THE PHILLIPS CURVE

“POST KEYNESIAN” AND “NEW KEYNESIAN” ECONOMICS

6: The Second World War and Hayek’s Road to Serfdom

THE NAZIS COME TO POWER

THE INTERVENTIONIST DYNAMIC IN NAZI ECONOMIC POLICY

WERNER SOMBART AND THE GERMAN HISTORICAL SCHOOLS

PLANNING DOCTRINES IN BRITAIN AND AMERICA

THE POLITICAL IMPLICATIONS OF CENTRAL PLANNING

BEYOND THE SOCIALIST CALCULATION DEBATE

“WHY THE WORST GET ON TOP”

THE TRAGEDY OF CENTRAL PLANNING: UNINTENDED POLITICAL RESULTS

THE ALTERNATIVE PATH

THE BOOK’S RECEPTION

POLITICAL BLOWBACK IN UNITED KINGDOM

7: Postwar British Socialism and the Fabian Society

THE GENERAL ELECTION OF 1945

LABOUR IN POWER

THE FABIAN SOCIALIST ROOTS OF LABOUR POLICY

SIDNEY AND BEATRICE WEBB

GEORGE BERNARD SHAW

HAROLD J. LASKI

WILLIAM BEVERIDGE

THE FABIAN VIEW OF ECONOMIC HISTORY

FABIAN ECONOMICS AND RICARDIAN RENT THEORY

HENRY GEORGE

FROM GEORGISM TO THE NATIONALIZATION OF LAND AND CAPITAL

JEREMY BENTHAM

UTILITARIANISM AND ECONOMIC POLICY

JOHN STUART MILL

J. S. MILL BETWEEN BENTHAM AND THE FABIANS

8: The Mont Pelerin Society and the Rebirth of Smithian Economics

THE POSTWAR CLIMATE OF OPINION

HAYEK FOUNDS THE MONT PELERIN SOCIETY

THE RATIONALE FOR AN INTERNATIONAL SOCIETY OF CLASSICAL LIBERALS

THE CLASSICAL LIBERAL TRADITION

THE SPIRIT OF ADAM SMITH

ADAM SMITH

ADAM SMITH AS INTELLECTUAL TOUCHSTONE AND ICON

THE FIRST MESSAGE OF THE WEALTH OF NATIONS

HOW THE DIVISION OF LABOR PROMOTES PROSPERITY

THE “INVISIBLE HAND” OF THE MARKET

THE ROLES OF GOVERNMENT

SMITH ON MONEY AND BANKING

NOT A SHILL FOR BUSINESS INTERESTS

INFLUENCES ON SMITH: FRANCIS HUTCHESON AND BERNARD MANDEVILLE

DAVID HUME AND ADAM FERGUSON

THE PHYSIOCRATS

THE PROBLEM OF SOCIAL COORDINATION

CARL MENGER

MENGER’S THEORY OF PRICE FORMATION

THE EMERGENCE OF MONEY

POLICY IMPLICATIONS OF SPONTANEOUS ORDER THEORY

9: The Postwar German “Wonder Economy” and Ordoliberalism

OCCUPIED GERMANY, 1945–8

ERHARD’S SHOCK THERAPY

LUDWIG ERHARD

ORDOLIBERALISM

THE SEARCH FOR AN APPROPRIATE CONSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK

WALTER EUCKEN

WILHELM RÖPKE

COMPETITION POLICY

RENT-SEEKING

ORDOLIBERALISM TODAY

10: Indian Planning and Development Economics

WHICH DIRECTION FOR AN INDEPENDENT INDIA?

NEHRU’S OWN SOCIALISM

NEHRU’S ECONOMIC ADVISERS

PROPLANNING WESTERN ADVICE

GALBRAITH’S SUPPORT FOR INDIA’S PLANNING

THE MAHALANOBIS PLAN

INPUT-OUTPUT ANALYSIS

THE PERMIT RAJ

SLOW GROWTH

B. R. SHENOY

MILTON FRIEDMAN’S DISSENT

LIBERALIZATION

INDIA’S ONGOING DEBATE

DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS

PETER BAUER

THE CURRENT DEBATE OVER DEVELOPMENT

WHY DO SOME COUNTRIES REMAIN RICHER THAN OTHERS?

11: Bretton Woods and International Monetary Thought

THE CONFERENCE AT BRETTON WOODS

HOW AN INTERNATIONAL GOLD OR SILVER STANDARD WORKED

THE GLOBAL QUANTITY AND VALUE OF MONEY UNDER A GOLD OR SILVER STANDARD

HOW LARGE A PROBLEM WAS INFLATION FROM GOLD DISCOVERIES?

BIMETALLISM

BIMETALLISM AND INFLATIONISM

MARSHALL’S AND FISHER’S PROPOSALS FOR MODIFYING THE GOLD STANDARD

EXCHANGE RATES UNDER THE CLASSICAL GOLD STANDARD

DURING AND AFTER THE FIRST WORLD WAR

GOLDEN FETTERS?

THE BREAKDOWN OF BRETTON WOODS AND THE CLOSING OF THE GOLD WINDOW

THE GLOBAL MONETARY REGIME SINCE 1971

12: The Great Inflation and Monetarism

POSTWAR AMERICAN MONETARY POLICY

MILTON FRIEDMAN

FRIEDMAN AND SCHWARTZ ON THE GREAT DEPRESSION

WAS FRIEDMAN INCONSISTENT OR DISHONEST ABOUT THE GREAT DEPRESSION?

FRIEDMAN’S CRITIQUE OF KEYNESIAN ECONOMICS

THE QUANTITY THEORY OF MONEY

IRVING FISHER

HOW FAR BACK DOES THE QUANTITY THEORY GO?

THE QUANTITY THEORY IN MARSHALL

MONETARISM

KEYNESIANS VERSUS MONETARISTS ON INFLATION, INTEREST RATES, AND BUSINESS CYCLES

RULES FOR MONETARY POLICY

AUSTRIANS VERSUS MONETARISTS ON BUSINESS CYCLE THEORY

FRIEDMAN THE MARSHALLIAN VERSUS LUCAS THE WALRASIAN

THE LEGACY OF MONETARISM

13: The Growth of Government: Public Goods and Public Choice

THE POSTWAR GROWTH OF GOVERNMENT

WHAT ARE THE DESIRABLE ROLES OF GOVERNMENT IN THE ECONOMY?

VILFREDO PARETO

THE THEORY OF PUBLIC GOODS

FREE-RIDING, PRICING, AND MARKET FAILURE

PUBLIC GOODS AND EXTERNAL BENEFITS

ARTHUR C. PIGOU

OTHER POOR EXAMPLES

RONALD COASE

COASE’S ANALYSIS OF SOCIAL COST

INCOME TRANSFERS AS A PUBLIC GOOD

PUBLIC CHOICE AND THE PROBLEM OF RENT-SEEKING

CONSTITUTIONALISM

14: Free Trade, Protectionism, and Trade Deficits

SHRINKING TARIFFS, GROWING TRADE

FREE TRADE AND ITS CRITICS

ADAM SMITH’S CRITIQUE OF MERCANTILISM

COMPARATIVE ADVANTAGE AND THE CORN LAW

POPULAR AGITATION AGAINST THE CORN LAW, DERIVED FROM SMITHIAN POLITICAL ECONOMY

THE INFANT INDUSTRY ARGUMENT FOR PROTECTION, AND ADAM SMITH’S REBUTTAL

ALEXANDER HAMILTON’S CASE AGAINST FREE TRADE

FRIEDRICH LIST’S CASE FOR PROTECTING INFANT INDUSTRIES

HENRY SIDGWICK’S THEORETICAL ARGUMENT AND RECENT LITERATURE

PROTECTIONISM IN PURSUIT OF FREE TRADE?

DO TRADE DEFICITS POINT TO A FLAW IN FREE TRADE?

15: From Pleasant Deficit Spending to Unpleasant Sovereign Debt Crisis

SOVEREIGN DEBT CRISES HIT GREECE AND IRELAND

THE KEYNESIAN CHALLENGE TO ORTHODOX FISCAL THEORY

ARE MOST BUDGET DEFICITS PLEASANT EVENTS?

WHO BEARS THE BURDEN OF DEBT?

THE GOVERNMENT BUDGET CONSTRAINT AND THE INCENTIVE TO BORROW

RICARDIAN EQUIVALENCE

INCENTIVE EFFECTS OF TAXES AND THE LAFFER CURVE

THE KEYNESIAN MULTIPLIER

THE GOVERNMENT’S TEMPTATION TO INFLATE AWAY ITS DEBT

UNPLEASANT MONETARIST ARITHMETIC

Index

The users who browse this book also browse


No browse record.