Building the Constitution :The Practice of Constitutional Interpretation in Post-Apartheid South Africa ( Cambridge Studies in Constitutional Law )

Publication subTitle :The Practice of Constitutional Interpretation in Post-Apartheid South Africa

Publication series :Cambridge Studies in Constitutional Law

Author: James Fowkes  

Publisher: Cambridge University Press‎

Publication year: 2016

E-ISBN: 9781316868133

P-ISBN(Paperback): 9781107124097

Subject: D91 Legal departments

Keyword: 法学各部门

Language: ENG

Access to resources Favorite

Disclaimer: Any content in publications that violate the sovereignty, the constitution or regulations of the PRC is not accepted or approved by CNPIEC.

Building the Constitution

Description

This revisionary perspective on South Africa's celebrated Constitutional Court draws on historical and empirical sources alongside conventional legal analysis to show how support from the African National Congress government and other political actors has underpinned the Court's landmark cases, which are often applauded too narrowly as merely judicial achievements. Standard accounts see the Court as overseer of a negotiated constitutional compromise and as the looked-to guardian of that constitution against the rising threat of the ANC. However, in reality South African successes have been built on broader and more admirable constitutional politics to a degree no previous account has described or acknowledged. The Court has responded to this context with a substantially consistent but widely misunderstood pattern of deference and intervention. Although a work in progress, this institutional self-understanding represents a powerful effort by an emerging court, as one constitutionally serious actor among others, to build a constitution.

Chapter

Beyond Makwanyane

2 Taking Reality (Legally) Seriously

The Work of the Constitution-Building Court

Realism, Law and Karl Llewellyn

Strategy, Legal Legitimacy and Alexander Bickel

Dworkin, Ackerman and the Relevance of Political Activity to Interpretation

3 Voting Rights, Politics and Trust

Rereading NNP

The Constitution-Building Court at Work: Structural Concerns in NNP

Democracy and Trust

Epilogue to NNP

Consistency: NNP and the Rest of the Court’s Voting Rights Jurisprudence

Another NNP v. ANC

4 The Role of the Court: Standard Conceptions

The Intentions of the Drafters

Institutional Thinking during the Transition - the ANC

Institutional Thinking during the Transition - the NP and Other Minority Groups

The Court as an Actor in an Elite Pact

Post-Apartheid Judging and Transformative Constitutionalism

Bridge-Building

5 The Role of the Court: Constitution-Building

The Constitution-Building Account and Newness

Infrastructure

The Public Status of Ideas

An Illustration: HIV/AIDS Discrimination

The Text and Its Questions: Constitution-Building as a Constitutional Argument

Purposive Text and Results-Driven Constitutionalism

6 LGBTI Equality

The Emerging Public Status of LGBTI Equality in South Africa

The Two National Coalition Decisions: Criminalization and Immigration Law

The Two Fourie Decisions: Same-Sex Marriage

Decisions to Decide, and Not to Decide: Family Law for Unmarried Couples

7 Democracy

Doctors for Life

Extending the Lines: The Later Public Participation Cases

Promoting Democracy within Parliament and Local Government Structures

UDM (2) and the Brief Life of Floor-Crossing

Epilogue to UDM (2)

8 Socio-economic Rights

Rights and Newness

Maximalism in Socio-economic Rights Cases: Grootboom, PE Municipality, and Joseph

Non-Intervention Decisions: Soobramoney, Nokotyana and Grootboom

Minister of Health v. Treatment Action Campaign

Mazibuko v. City of Johannesburg

9 Equality, Eviction and Engagement

The Promise of Legislative Action: Masiya and Volks v. Robinson

Deferring into Space: S v. Lawrence and S v. Jordan

Meaningful Engagement: Adjusting the Constitution-Building Equation

Engagement and Its Possibilities: From Eviction to Prince to the Future

Conclusion

Bibliography

South African Constitutions, Statutes and Bills

Other South African Official Sources

Books, Articles and Book Chapters

Other sources

Index

The users who browse this book also browse


No browse record.