Worse than the Disease :Pitfalls of Medical Progress

Publication subTitle :Pitfalls of Medical Progress

Author: Diana Barbara Dutton; Thomas A. Preston; Nancy E. Pfund  

Publisher: Cambridge University Press‎

Publication year: 1992

E-ISBN: 9780511872600

P-ISBN(Paperback): 9780521395571

Subject: R-05 medical relationship with other subjects

Keyword: 工业技术理论

Language: ENG

Access to resources Favorite

Disclaimer: Any content in publications that violate the sovereignty, the constitution or regulations of the PRC is not accepted or approved by CNPIEC.

Worse than the Disease

Description

This book examines four medical innovations that epitomize the pitfalls of progress: DES, a synthetic estrogen prescribed to millions of women to prevent miscarriages, which produced devastating side effects; the artificial heart; the 1976 swine flu immunization program; and genetic engineering. Dutton and the contributors trace the human choices that govern medical and scientific innovation and explore the political, economic, and social factors that influence those choices. In the process, they reveal a deep gulf between the priorities of medical innovation and the concerns of the general public. They then propose concrete policy changes to help bridge that gulf.

Chapter

FDA: public protector or corporate coach?

FDA approval and the failure of regulatory safeguards

The new antimiscarriage drug

The FDA approves DES for use in pregnancy

Prenatal use persists despite evidence of inefficacy

Plumper chickens, bulkier beef

The FDA - reluctant regulator

Another use for DES: from pregnancy enhancer to pregnancy terminator

The cancer link: local initiative, FDA inertia

Congress intervenes

Prenatal DES: the failure to inform

Getting DES out of meat: winning the battle and losing the war

The rise and fall of the DES morning-after pill

Conclusion

4 The artificial heart

The history of the artificial heart

The federal connection

The political background

The NIH artificial heart program

The erosion of optimism

The redirection of the NIH program

The breakaway of the Utah heart

The commercial ingredient

The Barney Clark experiment

Marketing the operation

The corporate takeover

Conclusion

5 The swine flu immunization program

The new flu

Sencer decides

Cooper endorses

Ford announces

A shaky start

More problems and mounting opposition

The impasse over liability

Immunization begins - finally

Guillain-Barre syndrome and the program's demise

Legacies and lessons

6 Genetic engineering: science and social responsibility

The early years: scientists' fears

The controversy goes public

The breaking of consensus: the emergence of dissident scientists

Recombinant DNA goes to Congress

Taking it to the streets: recombinant DNA at the local level

Exit research controversy

NIH reform: form versus content

DNA hits Wall Street

Of boomtown and gown

Biotechnology: R for the economy

Genetic futures

Continuing controversies: hubris and humility

Conclusion

Part III Lessons, questions, and challenges

7 Risks and rights

Varying perceptions of risks (or, The risk you see depends on where you sit)

Of risks and doctors

The patient's right to informed consent

Informed consent and medical experimentation

Risks to society

Changing attitudes toward collective risks

The politics of risk

Risk assessment: analysis and ideology

Beyond risks and benefits

8 Compensating the injuries of medical innovation

Injury compensation: goals and problems

DES lawsuits: who pays when drugs cause injuries?

A new view of medical risks

Breaking new legal ground

Liability for immunization injuries: lessons from the swine flu program

Injuries due to medical experimentation

New problems, new solutions

Joint litigation

Toxic torts

Broader manufacturer liability

Social insurance

Social insurance with liability funding

Conclusion

9 What is fair? Medical innovation and justice

What is "justice" in medical innovation?

Access to scarce resources: Are some more equal than others?

Access to the artificial heart

Resource allocation in an era of medical limits

Covert rationing, overt injustice

Private profit at public expense

Roots of the paradox

Conclusion

10 The role of the public

The nature of public concerns

Reassessing risks and benefits

Soft issues and hard choices: broadening and humanizing biomedical policy

Democratizing decisions

The impact of public efforts

Keys to public involvement and influence

Barriers and boundaries

Questions and arguments about public participation

11 What is possible? Toward medical progress in the public interest

Common pitfalls in decisionmaking

Present realities, future visions

Individual and collective risks

Compensation of injured victims

Allocation of health resources

The central dilemma: lack of public accountability

Making medicine more publicly accountable

Final words

Notes

Index

The users who browse this book also browse