The Role of Emotions in Criminal Law Defences :Duress, Necessity and Lesser Evils

Publication subTitle :Duress, Necessity and Lesser Evils

Author: Eimear Spain;  

Publisher: Cambridge University Press‎

Publication year: 2011

E-ISBN: 9781316964286

P-ISBN(Paperback): 9781107008182

P-ISBN(Hardback):  9781107008182

Subject: D914 刑法

Keyword: 法律

Language: ENG

Access to resources Favorite

Disclaimer: Any content in publications that violate the sovereignty, the constitution or regulations of the PRC is not accepted or approved by CNPIEC.

Description

Examines the role of emotions in criminal behaviour, and their importance to the attribution of moral and criminal responsibility. Eimear Spain's proposal for an explicit engagement with emotion theory in the criminal law will be of interest to a range of legal scholars and advanced students interested in the substantive criminal law or law and emotion scholarship. Eimear Spain's proposal for an explicit engagement with emotion theory in the criminal law will be of interest to a range of legal scholars and advanced students interested in the substantive criminal law or law and emotion scholarship. The law has struggled for many years with the problem of how to accommodate those who commit crimes due to threats or circumstances. The modern ambivalence surrounding the defences of duress and necessity has its origins in the legal past. To date the defences of duress and necessity have been couched in terms such as compulsion, involuntariness and human frailty, resulting in the true nature of the defences being hidden. Psychologists and legal theorists have begun to re-examine the role of emotions in human action, including their effect upon behaviour and choice. In light of recent breakthroughs, Eimear Spain considers how the emotions experienced by those who act due to threats, both human and natural in origin, should affect the attribution of criminal responsibility and punishment. The understanding of emotions extrapolated in this book points towards a new rationale for the existing defences of duress and necessity. 1. Thematic overview; 2. The role of emotions in legal theory; 3. Structure of the defences; 4. Elements of the defences; 5. Threats and the taking of life; 6. A reappraisal.

Chapter

Law on attempts

Law and morality

Involuntariness

Voluntarist rationales

Compelled or chosen actions

Basis of evaluation

Objective versus subjective

Agent relative versus agent neutral standard

Justification versus excuse

Relevance of the distinction

Excuses

Justifications

Duress and necessity as excuses or justifications

Genuine defences?

Traditional view

Modern approach

Conclusion

2 The role of emotions in legal theory

Psychological literature

The origins of emotion

Cognitive appraisal theory

Emotions as thoughts

Emotional appraisal system

Features of emotion under differing theories

Conscious and unconscious appraisals

Duration of emotions

Automatic responses

Function of emotions

Rationality of emotions

Rational emotions

Irrational emotions

Emotions and morality

Conclusion

3 Coping with uncertainty

Recognition of the defences

English cases and commentaries

US cases

Conclusion

Creative approaches

Statutory interpretation

Prosecutorial discretion

Jury nullification

Mitigation or acquittal

Flexibility

Charter for terrorism

Administrative measures

Stigma of conviction

Considerations of rationale

Punishment

Conclusion

4 Elements of the defences

Level of threats

Duress

Types of harm

Property/reputation

False imprisonment

Mental injury

Necessity

Harm averted

Previous conduct

Duress

Voluntary exposure

Relaxation of rules

Necessity

Standard of assessment

Duress

Who is the reasonable man?

Is an objective criterion necessary?

Varying forms of the objective test

Relevant characteristics

Duress of circumstances/necessity

Relationship between the parties

Duress

Proximity of the relationship

Assumption of responsibility

Superfluous requirement

Necessity

Timing of the threat

Duress

Overlap

Appearance of restriction

Necessity/duress of circumstances

Conclusion

5 Threats and the taking of life

Historical authorities

Larceny

War and crimes against the Crown

Murder and duress

Murder and necessity

Case law

Necessity as a defence to murder

Duress as a defence to murder

Degrees of heinousness

Importance of intention or result

Themes

Divorce of law from morality

Evaluation of worth of victims

Abuse of the defence

Duty of self-sacrifice

Sanctity of life

Conclusion

6 A reappraisal

Reformulated duress defence

Voluntariness

Judging emotion

Limitations

Theoretical framework

The reformulated defence in operation

Lesser evils defence

Limitations

Theoretical framework

The reformulated defence in operation

Conclusion

INDEX

The users who browse this book also browse