Politics, Gender, and Concepts :Theory and Methodology

Publication subTitle :Theory and Methodology

Author: Gary Goertz; Amy G. Mazur  

Publisher: Cambridge University Press‎

Publication year: 2008

E-ISBN: 9780511460838

P-ISBN(Paperback): 9780521897761

Subject: G3 Science , Scientific Research

Keyword: 科学、科学研究

Language: ENG

Access to resources Favorite

Disclaimer: Any content in publications that violate the sovereignty, the constitution or regulations of the PRC is not accepted or approved by CNPIEC.

Politics, Gender, and Concepts

Description

A critique of concepts has been central to feminist scholarship since its inception. However, while gender scholars have identified the analytical gaps in existing social science concepts, few have systematically mapped out a gendered approach to issues in political analysis and theory development. This volume addresses this important gap in the literature by exploring the methodology of concept construction and critique, which is a crucial step to disciplined empirical analysis, research design, causal explanations, and testing hypotheses. Leading gender and politics scholars use a common framework to discuss methodological issues in some of the core concepts of feminist research in political science, including representation, democracy, welfare state governance, and political participation. This is an invaluable work for researchers and students in women's studies and political science.

Chapter

Context Guideline

Traveling Guideline

Causal Relationships Guideline

Naming Guideline

Negation Guideline

Zones Guideline

Dimensions Guideline

Necessity Guideline

Interdependence Guideline

Operationalization Guideline

Conclusion

PART I GENDERING CONCEPTS

3 Gendering democracy

Context Guideline: definitions of democracy

Naming Guideline: women are implicitly part of the definition of democracy

Dimensions Guideline: the necessity of participation

Negation Guideline

Operationalization Guideline: women removed

Examples of the discrepancy in transition or stability measures

Examples of the discrepancy in graded measures

Zones Guideline: gendering democracy through the "gray zone"

Traveling Guideline: one consequence of women's exclusion

Causal Relationships Guideline: more implications of gendering democracy

The emergence of democracy

The age and regional prevalence of democracy

The causes of democracy

Conclusion

4 Gendering representation

The context of political representation

Gendering representation? Naming the concept

Dimensions of political representation

Who are the actors?

Representation as a formal participation and as “standing for”

Gendering formal and descriptive representation

What and who is represented (and by whom)?

Representation as “acting for”

Gendering substantive representation

Necessity and interdependency of the dimensions

Representation versus nonrepresentation, and the zones in between

Empirical research on gendering representation

Research on women’s formal, descriptive and substantive representation

Making the concept travel

Traditional and feminist women’s interests

Interests of the women’s movement

Conclusion

5 Gendering the welfare state

The concept of the welfare state

The comparativist turn

Strategies to gender comparative welfare state research

Highlighting gender separately

The gender division of labor

The care dimension

Building gender in

Concept dimensions and operationalizations

Gender stratification

Beyond decommodification

Impact on the concept

6 Gendering governance

The context: the origins and meaning of governance

Naming the concept and its dimensions: how does this relate to gender?

The dimensions of the concept

The market

The public and the private

The state

Networks

Operationalizing the concept: global governance

Conclusions: toward a gendered concept of governance

7 Gendering development

Geographic scope

Shifting contexts, changing names: historical perspectives

Colonial beginnings: pervasive racism and sexism

The absence of negations in all-gray zones

Economic paradigms

Comprehensive research, plus feminist critiques: 1970+

Adding new dimensions and their interdependence: entrées for women and gender

Necessity: economic growth and/or redistribution

From women’s politics to gender and the triumph of capitalism

The gender lens: what difference does/might it make?

Operationalization Guideline

Gender-disaggregated data

HDI, GDI, and GEM: numeric advances, yet flaws

Traveling Guideline

Causal Relationships Guideline

Concluding reflections

PART II GENDER-SPECIFIC CONCEPTS

8 Gender ideology: masculinism and feminalism

Getting to masculinism and feminalism via gender ideology

Context

The emergence of gender ideology: patriarchy and feminism

On naming, negation, and gray zones

Names, negations, and absences

The evolution to masculinism

Gender ideology as protoideology

Getting to feminalism

Gender ideology and complexity

Interdependence: a large gray zone

Inserting gender into political ideology: dimensions and necessity

The “that” of “that which”: content of operationalization

From gender to gender ideology: operationalization

Feminalism and its utility for studying gender ideology

On traveling: feminalism and the positive pole

Causality and conclusions

9 Intersectionality

What is intersectionality? The context of the concept

"Naming" intersectionality as a new concept: beyond dual systems and triple burdens

A problem with the contemporary understanding of intersectionality

Possible solutions

Can the concept of intersectionality "travel"?

Operationalizing intersectionality

Application to study of the welfare state

An intersectional analysis of the welfare state

Summary of evaluation and comparison of the two approaches using the Guidelines

Implications for political practice: intersectionality as a model for practice

Conclusion

10 Women's movements, feminism, and feminist movements

Theory and research context (Context Guideline)

Democracy and democratization

The state and states

Social movements

Women and politics

Gender and power

Transnational activism and global issues

The RNGS project

Building the concepts: women's movement and feminist movement

Concept 1: women’s movement

The basic level

The secondary level

Empirical indicators

Social movement and women’s movement: what is the connection?

Concept 2: feminism and feminist movement

Basic and secondary levels

Empirical indicators

Research application of "feminism" and "feminist movement": will the RNGS concepts travel?

Apply indicators of feminism in the research context

Look for the women’s movement, not the feminists

Canmen be feminists?

Conclusion

11 State feminism

Naming state feminism: toward a focus on WPA–WM relations

Phase 1: Nordic state feminism in the 1980s

Phase II: Australian femocracy in the early 1990s

Phase III: A cross-national approach to WPA–WM relations from 1995 to the present

The theoretical context for state feminism

Democracy, representation, and participation

New institutionalism

Social movements

A search for the drivers of state feminism through comparative analysis

The structure of state feminism as a concept

Operationalizing state feminism in the RNGS project

Does state feminism travel?

Silences on state feminism

Making state feminism travel

Conclusion

Appendix A website for additional gender and politics concepts

References

Index

The users who browse this book also browse