Description
This collection considers the relevance of the Annales 'school' for archaeology. The Annales movement regarded orthodox history as too much concerned with events, too narrowly political, too narrative in form and too isolated from neighbouring disciplines. Annalistes attempted to construct a 'total' history, dealing with a wide range of human activity, and combining divergent material, documentary, and theoretical approaches to the past. Annales-oriented research utilizes the techniques and tools of various ancillary fields, and integrates temporal, spatial, material and behavioural analyses. Such an approach is obviously attractive to archaeologists, for even though they deal with material data rather than social facts, they are just as much as historians interested in understanding social, economic and political factors such as power and dominance, conflict, exchange and other human activities. Three introductory essays consider the relationship between Annales methodology and current archaeological theory. Case studies draw upon methodological variations of the multifaceted Annales approach. The volume concludes with two overviews, one historical and the other archaeological.
Chapter
1 Archaeology and Annales: time, space and change
Origins: the Annales tradition
Annales, archaeology, social theory and time
Theoretical constructs and case studies
Annales: retrospect and prospect
PART I THEORETICAL CONSTRUCTS
2 Braudel's temporal rhythms and chronology theory in archaeology
Archaeology as a historical science
Rhythms of temporal change in history and archaeology
Braudel and chronology theory
Binford, Schiffer, and the "Pompeu premise" in Americanist archaeology
Binford's distinction between ethnographic and archaeological time
periodization and chronological refinement
Chronological refinement and archaeological g
Temporal rhythms and cultural reconstruction
Braudel and cultural reconstruction
"Household archaeology" and time: some problems
3 Time perspectivism, Annales, and the potential of archaeology
The achievements of the Annales
An Annales hierarchy of time scales
The scale of the material
The problems of an Annaliste approach
Hierarchies of explanation, time perspectivism, and archaeology
The role of explanatory hierarchies
Indeterminacy and scales of process
The role of uniformitarianism
Time perspectivism and rates of cultural process
4 Rhythms of change in Postclassic central Mexico: archaeology, ethnohistory, and the Braudelian model
The archaeological record for Postclassic central Mexico
The Early Postclassic period
The Middle Postclassic period
The Late Postclassic period
Major trends in the Postclassic archaeological record
Chronological refinement in Postclassic central Mexico
Central Mexican ethnohistory
The nature of the sources
The chronicle of native history
Diachronic correlation of archaeology and ethnohistory
Political and military processes
Temporal rhythms in Postclassic central Mexico
5 Pottery styles and social status in medieval Khurasan
6 Independence and imperialism: politicoeconomic structures in the Bronze Age Levant
The dilemma of interpretation
Archaeological and documentary data
Archaeological data (Table 6.1)
Complexity and collapse in the southern Levant
Political structures and political power: an Annales perspective
7 Braudel and North American archaeology: an example from the Northern Plains
The contribution of Annales
Cultural setting: the historic Blackfoot
Procurement and processing as long-term structures
Historic period gender relations
8 Restoring the dialectic: settlement patterns and documents in medieval central Italy
Archaeology and the Annales
The search for an objective past
Texts and settlements in early medieval central Italy
PART III OVERVIEW AND PROSPECTS
9 Annales and archaeology
10 What can archaeologists learn from Annalistes?
The history of a difference
The lessons for archaeology