Investigation of E. coli and Virus Reductions Using Replicate, Bench-Scale Biosand Filter Columns and Two Filter Media

Author： Elliott Mark   Stauber Christine E.   DiGiano Francis A.   Fabiszewski de Aceituno Anna   Sobsey Mark D.  

Publisher： MDPI

E-ISSN： 1660-4601|12|9|10276-10299

ISSN： 1660-4601

Source： International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, Vol.12, Iss.9, 2015-08, pp. : 10276-10299

Access to resources Favorite

Disclaimer: Any content in publications that violate the sovereignty, the constitution or regulations of the PRC is not accepted or approved by CNPIEC.

Previous Menu Next

Abstract

The biosand filter (BSF) is an intermittently operated, household-scale slow sand filter for which little data are available on the effect of sand composition on treatment performance. Therefore, bench-scale columns were prepared according to the then-current (2006–2007) guidance on BSF design and run in parallel to conduct two microbial challenge experiments of eight-week duration. Triplicate columns were loaded with Accusand silica or crushed granite to compare virus and E. coli reduction performance. Bench-scale experiments provided confirmation that increased schmutzdecke growth, as indicated by decline in filtration rate, is the primary factor causing increased E. coli reductions of up to 5-log10. However, reductions of challenge viruses improved only modestly with increased schmutzdecke growth. Filter media type (Accusand silica vs. crushed granite) did not influence reduction of E. coli bacteria. The granite media without backwashing yielded superior virus reductions when compared to Accusand. However, for columns in which the granite media was first backwashed (to yield a more consistent distribution of grains and remove the finest size fraction), virus reductions were not significantly greater than in columns with Accusand media. It was postulated that a decline in surface area with backwashing decreased the sites and surface area available for virus sorption and/or biofilm growth and thus decreased the extent of virus reduction. Additionally, backwashing caused preferential flow paths and deviation from plug flow; backwashing is not part of standard BSF field preparation and is not recommended for BSF column studies. Overall, virus reductions were modest and did not meet the 5- or 3-log10 World Health Organization performance targets.

Related content

Correction: Stauber, C.E., et al. Evaluation of the Impact of the Plastic BioSand Filter on Health and Drinking Water Quality in rural Tamale, Ghana. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2012, 9, 3806–3823

By Stauber Christine E.   Kominek Byron   Liang Kaida R.   Osman Mumuni K.   Sobsey Mark D.  

International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, Vol. 11, Iss. 9, 2014-09 ,pp. : 9154-9155 (2)

MDPI

Access to resources Recommend Favorite

Evaluation of the Impact of the Plastic BioSand Filter on Health and Drinking Water Quality in Rural Tamale, Ghana

By Stauber Christine E.   Kominek Byron   Liang Kaida R.   Osman Mumuni K.   Sobsey Mark D.  

International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, Vol. 9, Iss. 11, 2012-10 ,pp. : 3806-3823 (18)

MDPI

Access to resources Recommend Favorite

On-Line Monitoring the Growth of E. coli or HeLa Cells Using an Annular Microelectrode Piezoelectric Biosensor

By Tong Feifei   Lian Yan   Han Junliang  

International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, Vol. 13, Iss. 12, 2016-12 ,pp. : 1254-1254 (1)

MDPI

Access to resources Recommend Favorite

Are Filter-Tipped Cigarettes Still Less Harmful than Non-Filter Cigarettes?—A Laser Spectrometric Particulate Matter Analysis from the Non-Smokers Point of View

By Schulz Maria   Gerber Alexander   Groneberg David A.  

International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, Vol. 13, Iss. 4, 2016-04 ,pp. : 429-429 (1)

MDPI

Access to resources Recommend Favorite

Qualitative Analysis of E-Liquid Emissions as a Function of Flavor Additives Using Two Aerosol Capture Methods

By Eddingsaas Nathan   Pagano Todd   Cummings Cody   Rahman Irfan   Robinson Risa   Hensel Edward  

International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, Vol. 15, Iss. 2, 2018-02 ,pp. : 323-323 (1)

MDPI

Access to resources Recommend Favorite